Our rating criteria

Thomas - founder / mad of backpacks -

How do we rate the bags we test?

Very simply: we have a list of criteria to which we give a score out of 10, and then average them out. We chose these criteria for their objectivity. Nevertheless, there will always be an element of subjectivity, often inexplicable, linked to experience with the product. That's why we also take your feedback into account! So don't hesitate to let us know.

Usage ./5

- Functionality and organization: does the bag have several inside and outside pockets? Are they easily accessible and visible? Are they scratch or zip fasteners? Is the bag easy to use? Is it easy to open and close, store and clean?

- Ergonomics: does the bag have compression straps and sufficient adjustability? Is the back designed to fit the body and/or circulate air? Does it have a belt and/or sternum strap? Has it been designed so as not to get in the way when you're on the move? Is it comfortable?

- Waterproofing: does the bag fully or partially protect its contents from the rain?

- Abrasion resistance: is the bag designed to resist rubbing and wear?

- Tear resistance: is the bag designed to resist tears and cuts?

Technical ./5

- Fabrics: Are the fabrics used of high quality? Eco-friendly? Suitable for the bag's functions? Can we find out who makes them and where they come from?

- Accessories: are the buckles, clips, straps, Velcro fasteners and silkscreen prints used of good quality? Can you tell us who made them and where they come from?

- Assembly and stitching: are fabrics and accessories correctly assembled? Are seams correctly positioned and reinforced? Are the most stressed areas of the bag reinforced?

- Innovations: Does the bag feature innovative, differentiating materials or accessories? Has its weight been optimized? Are its use and functions innovative?

- Manufacturer's warranty: How far does the manufacturer's warranty extend? For how long?